每日吃瓜

eangola wrote:

leatherback wrote:
No matter how much you dislike it, trees typically need foliage closer to the trunk. Otherwise you will end up with ponpons instead of bonsai.. The way you go about rejecting this shows how many more trees you have to study. Trust me, i know literati. And I also know it is the most dificult ones, next to windswept to do realistically.

i suppose you think it is constructive to tell people they can achieve something. I think it is constructive to tell people there are limits what can be achieved with certain plants.

So instead of criticizing, or attacking each other on this forum, we should stick to seeing each other point of view.
I learned, SerGO learned, and maybe you learned as well. There was really no point on attacking me about my dead, mistreated Juniper, on a forum that has nothing to do with that. There is a topic on that tree somewhere else on the forums where you can say whatever you want. Having a 90% success rate with re-potting on my first time, I am pretty damn sure I know how and when to re-pot a tree now. I didn't back then, but I am pretty sure you didn't either before you started.

@ engola, thank you for pointing this out, that is the reason I posted "I can't help myself" in the cafe section, we may continue to discuss this there further and leave this topic alone, I really appreciate that you, now, also understand what I talk about, thanks.
@SerGO, I have killed about 10++ trees, mostly do to be in a hurry. Back to your trees, read the good out of what you can use, delete the rest out of your mind, its not worse to argument with some people, I tried.
Your trees are perfectly nice, not only for you, but me too, I love the Idea you like to follow, so go for it!!!!!! I will follow your post and help you as much as I can, but unfortunately the Tropics is not a pine country. However, Graham Potter of Kaizen 每日吃瓜, and Ryan Neil of Mira bonsai have good videos on pine. Neil has a special pine tutorial with so much information that you have to watch it 4-6 times to get all the information absorbed. So go for that first, and meanwhile let your tree grow until you have more information.

My tip, get the tree out of the pot and build yourself a big box so it can produce more roots and thicken up a bit more. My mistake and that of every beginner, to fast to furious is not good for trees. I got 120 ++ trees, old young from sticks to big chunky trunks, all take time. I only posted a fraction of what is to come, stay cool don't react on anything you don't need, have fun. Thanks for sharing, people like you make this forum better, because we all learn from your mistakes too.

Strictly on-topic from here on please.

Thank you, very detailed answers , I live in Siberia , so that there will be problems with hibernation .
每日吃瓜 is a sculpture on which you can work a lifetime ...

why die ?

To wet?! Fungus, try different medium, sand based

seems like the root was chewed off. Have you seen small fly-like animals around the pot? COuld be the work of gnats' larvae.

?

Try repotting this into a pot with fresh potting medium, plant fairly deep (up to the first green in the stem) in dappled shade